Estimated value

Buying options

Tasting notes

Tasting notes
Score 90/100 · Pierre Rovani, Oct 1998

This wine confounded me. I fell in love with its medium-to-dark ruby-colored aromatics at the winery. It revealed perfumed layers of super-ripe cherries, plums, and violets with just a touch of spicy oak. On the palate its seductive personality offered chewy-textured, mouth-coating, and concentrated waves of gorgeously sweet red and black fruits. Revisited three times since, it twice smelled of spicy apple cider, was completely disjointed, and had a hard tannic finish. However, the third time was the charm. It was back to its original state, seducing me with its fresh, sweet, and complex aromatics and flavors. I purchased a case of this wine after my original tasting, and still have high hopes for it. Panther Creek's 1996s were sampled twice, once at the winery and later at a blind tasting in Washington, DC (I retasted the Freedom Hill a third and fourth time at home). At my winery tasting, serious rock and roll was being played in the background. Unbeknownst to Michael Stevenson, Panther Creek's Assistant Winemaker and Head Disc Jockey, he had selected music from my favorite rock group, The Band. As I contemplated the wines I could hear Levon Helm belting out "Don't do it". Want to know what goes great with Pinot Noir? Great rock and roll! The harvest began on the 9th of October, and finished as heavy rains began at 2pm on Saturday, October 12 - "we were luckier than smart" was owner Ron Kaplan's comment. Yields averaged 2 plus tons with a low of 2.01 tons per acre in Freedom Hill and a high of 2.4 tons in Shea (even though the latter vineyard was thinned three times). Kaplan says he is pleased with the vintage, and that "the grapes came in clean, without any traces of rot." He went on to say that the wines had "very pronounced aromatics, atypical for newborn wine." Tel. (503) 472-8080.

Critic scores

Critic scores
90
90/100

Average Score

89
89+/100

Stephen Tanzer, Vinous

90
90/100

Pierre Rovani

More reviews and scores

89+ points
Stephen Tanzer, Vinous
Score 89+/100 · Stephen Tanzer, Vinous

Saturated dark red. Slightly medicinal black cherry and mint aromas. Big, rich and mouthfilling, with excellent depth and solid underlying structure. Holds its acids nicely. Rather cool, slightly minty flavors are still tightly wrapped. Finishes rather backward, with fairly substantial, chewy tannins. Built to age.

About the producer

Panther Creek
View Producer

Product details

Colour

Red

Taste

Dry

Why Vinfolio?
Store
Store your collection in our temperature-controlled warehouse to guarantee the provenance of your wines
Deliver
We sell wines to customers and clients in over 60 countries and can organise delivery to almost anywhere on the planet.
Sell
With effortless listing, promotion to our extensive network and valuation advice, there's no easier way to sell wine in your collection
Get the best Vinfolio delivered in your inbox
Subscribe to our emails
Ⓒ 2026 Vinfolio. All rights reserved.