2005 Whetstone Syrah Guidici Family Vineyard
Estimated value
Buying options
Tasting notes
Tasting notes
Score 92+/100 · Stephen Tanzer, Vinous, May 2007
(bottled in February; the pinots were bottled last September) Deep ruby. Knockout nose combines deep minerality, smoked meat, bacon fat, violet and white pepper; very Northern Rhone in style. Then sweet, brisk and penetrating, with spicy, peppery lift to the powerful blackberry and violet flavors. The firm acids are perfectly integrated and the finish is peppery, gripping and long. This has a lower pH, and lower alcohol, than the 2004 and seems constructed to reveal greater nuance with time in bottle. Happily, Whetstone aged the wine in just 25% new oak.
Critic scores
Critic scores
92
92+/100
Stephen Tanzer, Vinous
About the producer
Whetstone Wine Cellars
Product details
Country / Region