2004 St Eden Cabernet Sauvignon

Dark red. Very ripe aromas of plum, currant and cocoa powder, complicated by a balsamic note and dusty minerality. At once savory and sweet, with the element of balsamic development carrying through onto the palate. Suave in texture but doesn't show the energy or delineation of the 2005 version. These tannins are finer-grained than I recall but the finish is a touch warm.

(14.5% alcohol): Bright, full ruby. Much more reserved on the nose than the Pluribus, hinting at blueberry, kirsch , menthol and violet. Supple and fine-grained but closed; less expressive than the Melbury, displaying a note of menthol that carries through the long, seriously tannic finish. Less evolved than the Melbury but I get a more interesting ripeness in that wine. This needs time. Coats the mouth on the back end without giving any impression of weightiness, leaving behind a minty element.

The 2004 St. Eden, which comes from a valley floor vineyard in Oakville, is another dead ringer for a great Pauillac, possibly a young Mouton. Dense bluish/purple in color with stunning notes of cedarwood, unsmoked high-quality cigar tobacco, crème de cassis and espresso roast, this wine has fabulous fruit, density and a full-bodied, youthful mouthfeel, wonderful balance and purity, and a terrific finish that goes on for close to a minute. This is also relatively open, but slightly more structured than the Melbury. There’s no sense deferring gratification, so I would suggest drinking it over the next 15-20 years, possibly longer. A brilliant project of Harlan Estates’ proprietor, Bill Harlan, these single-vineyard wines have been everything a Cabernet connoisseur could ever hope for since they were first released. Amazingly, these wines taste better with age than they did young, which is exactly what Harlan and his winemaking team of Bob Levy and consulting enologist Michel Rolland are trying to prove.