Advanced search

WinePost tips

Here are a few tips on how to make a compelling, Top 10 WinePost.
Being personal is the best way to start. Let's say you need to get across the simplicity of your box wine. Well, don't break out the French or Italian, bub!
Next, share a photo, or a video. It let's everyone see a more personal style.
That's all there is to it. Oh, remember you may only add up to 25 wines for each WinePost.

Related WinePosts

Wine and Spirits Top 100 by petesf
My friend and I were given tickets by our company to attend the Wine and...
1467 views Created Oct 15, 2009
2009 Wine & Spirits Top 100 by Bernadette
The annual Wine & Spirits Top 100 event sends many oenophiles into a...
2009 views Created Oct 15, 2009
Tasting of Grand Cru Burgundies from 2000 and 2001 by Ricknat1
Was at a great tasting hosted by David Hamburg at Acker last week with a...
1532 views Created Nov 3, 2009

1978 Burgundy Tasting


We tasted 13 Grand Crus in 5 flights over a dinner in the basement at Cru. This was masterfully planned and orchestrated by David Hamburg from Acker, who also was the guide through the evening.  The group of people were generally serious Burgundy lovers and many have been at this much, much longer than me.  Air was not a friend to most of these wines and for some of them the first minute was the best, while for others they improved over time, but most of them faded over 2 hours or so.  These should be popped and drunk.  The provenance of these wines were unquestioned, having been bought at release by a single collector and there were no storage problems.  Only one bottle was a clunker.  The fills were high, often top neck, at worst high shoulder/low neck and the color was good on all the wines.

The first flight started with the Joseph Faively Corton - Clos des Corton.  Faively has the reputation of making wines to last (or if you are cynical, that are perpetually too young.   The Corton stll has good color, slightly turning tawny.  Strong and powerful typical Corton nose but not as powerful in the mouth.  Still fresh, but not big.  nice, but unexceptional.  I enjoy the 1990 much more.  90.

The next wine was the Robert Arnoux Clos de Vougeot.  This was very much the opposite of its pairing.  lighter on the nose, it was powerful, earthy and spicy in the mouth with a rich finish.  Delicious.  surprisingly after a minute, the wine began to thin out.  Over an hour it got thinner.  It was still nice, but if you get a bottle, it needs to be drunk quite quickly.  91

The second flight started with a big hitter, the Vogue Musigny Vielles Vignes.  Since I had bought this at auction, I was nervous.  I was shocked by a big, huge animal nose that I did not expect.  In the mouth it was powerful, earthy, spicy and a little floral (in a nice way).  Lots of action and complexity in the finish. This is a wine of great structure, completely integrated with wonderful balance.  It has it all.  After an hour it was only getting bigger and stronger and it started to fade at 2 hours.  95

Next was the Mommessin Clos de Tart.  Allen Meadows gave this wine an 85 and in the bottle it looked brownish. In glass it looked fresh. Big Spicy nose. Typical CDT in the mouth but more so, rich, earthy, dried tea and white pepper and almost creamy in texture.  Very full and deep.  Strong at an hour, faded at 2.  There was a lot of debate with a minority believing this was the wine of the flight.  no question excellent and the best CDT I have had.  Definitely outperformed the lovely 1990 we had in August. 94

The final wine of the flight was the Giroud Charmes Chambertin.  At opening this wine was somewhat simple and monolithic.  After a few minutes, it was fruity and very nice.  In other company, it would be considered quite fine, but in this flight it could not stand up.  After 2 hours it developed more complexity and I upgraded my score from 90 to 91

Flight 3 began with the Dr. Georges Mugneret Ruchottes Chambertin.  This was a controversial wine, with some feeling that it was the true expression of it s terroir, but the company it was in made it tough.  it is a very fine wine with a rich , dark cherry nose.  In the mouth, it had more earth and less fruit with strong acidity and tannins present and plenty of life left.  This wine stood up well until finished and improved over the 2 hours it was open.  92

Next was the Maison Joseph Drouhin Chambertin.  Wow.  Knockout richness, strong fruit and power with great elegance.  Definitely a candidate for wine of the night.  This wine was everything it was trying to be and it is a pleasure.  96.

The last wine of the flight was the Clos de Beze and for several people, it was their favorite.  Complex,  spicy, real staying power and had the most going on in the flight.  a beautiful wine.  (One of the people said the spice was a pappidam pepper).  94

The fourth flight was the weakest flight of the night. It began with Mongeard-Mugneret Echezeaux which one person thought was the best expression they had experienced, but to me it had a spicy nose, aromatic complexity and was a little astringent on the finish (high alchohol?).  it was a nice Echezeaux, but did not compare to the 99 Dujac we had a few weeks ago.  91

Next was the Engel Grand Echezeaux and it started stronger, rich and creamy and my first note was gorgeous, which I crossed out on the second taste as it faded quickly.  91

The Charles Noellat Richebourg was the dud of the evening. Flat and funky. 80

The final flight was a knockout.  We started with the DRC Romanee St. Vivant.  Unbelievably rich, perfumed, elegant nose.  In the mouth, POP, dense, rich, round, integrated, fruity and elegant.  This is best RSV I have had.  It faded over an hour, but was still beautiful.   96

We finished with the Leroy Mazis Chambertin and this wine was all it as meant to be, truly revealing the terroir with a barnyardy, intense nose.  In the mouth it is pure power, wild and yet elegant at the same time.  This wine had the most stuffing of the night and was getting better and better as it was finished after an hour.  96

The Vogue, Clos de Tart, Clos de Beze, Drouhin, DRC and Leroy were outstanding experiences and i would buy any of these (money not being an issue) and drink again.  This was a great reference point for me with these wines.  A true delight.
Views: 1,831

What people are saying (0)

Login Register now
Year, Name, Varietal, Country, Region, Appellation, Color Drink dates Score(s)  
Leroy (Maison) - Mazis-Chambertin
1978 Leroy (Maison) - Mazis-Chambertin
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Gevrey Chambertin
95
Add comment
DRC - Romanee St Vivant (Marey Monge)
1978 DRC - Romanee St Vivant (Marey Monge)
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Vosne Romanee
Add comment
Charles Noellat - Richebourg
1978 Charles Noellat - Richebourg
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Vosne Romanee
80
Add comment
Rene Engel - Grands-Echezeaux
1978 Rene Engel - Grands-Echezeaux
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Flagey Echezeaux
91
Add comment
Mongeard-Mugneret - Echezeaux
1978 Mongeard-Mugneret - Echezeaux
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Flagey Echezeaux
91
Add comment
Faiveley - Chambertin Clos de Beze
1978 Faiveley - Chambertin Clos de Beze
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Gevrey Chambertin
94
Add comment
Joseph Drouhin - Chambertin
1978 Joseph Drouhin - Chambertin
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Gevrey Chambertin
Add comment
Georges Mugneret - Ruchottes-Chambertin
1978 Georges Mugneret - Ruchottes-Chambertin
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Gevrey Chambertin
Add comment
Camille Giroud - Charmes-Chambertin
1978 Camille Giroud - Charmes-Chambertin
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Gevrey Chambertin
91
Add comment
Mommessin - Clos de Tart
1978 Mommessin - Clos de Tart
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Morey St Denis
94
Add comment
Vogue - Musigny (Vieilles Vignes)
1978 Vogue - Musigny (Vieilles Vignes)
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Chambolle Musigny
Add comment
Robert Arnoux - Clos de Vougeot
1978 Robert Arnoux - Clos de Vougeot
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Nuits - Vougeot
Add comment
Faiveley - Corton Clos des Cortons Faiveley
1978 Faiveley - Corton Clos des Cortons Faiveley
Red Pinot Noir
France - Burgundy - Cote de Beaune - Corton
Add comment
Collapse wine comments