2007 Domaine Mugneret-Gibourg Vosne-Romanée

($68-$80) Medium red. Floral aromas of redcurrant, cherry and raspberry. Juicy and fresh, with some oak spice showing in the mouth. With its moderate flesh, this lively wine comes off as slightly tart on the end.

Author: Stephen Tanzer

Issue: March/April 2010

A similar if slightly more elegant nose leads to textured, velvety and round middle weight flavors that retain a lovely sense of detail as well as a subtle touch of minerality on the fresh, balanced and long finish. This is a quality villages that is very much worth a look.

Author: Allen Meadows

Issue: 1st Quarter, 2009

Lightly-cooked yet tart-edged blackberry and red currant; smoky black tea; game, moss, decadent woods, and underbrush scent the Mugneret 2007 Vosne Romanee and follow on a palate of infectious juiciness, leaving a dark berry stain and a wealth of herbal and mineral nuances ' if also a slight catch of tannin ' in its wake. This surprised me both for its depth and the bright edge to its fruit, and if followed for 4-6 years it might well gain some harmony while preserving nuance. Marie-Andree Mugneret points out that the trie de table had to be especially severe for this appellation.

Author: David Schildknecht

Sleek, dense, lively and smooth. This is successful! A really complex, complete village wine...

Author: Jancis Robinson