In the past 10 days or so, we have been going back and forth with Winesearcher about how "for sale" wine in the Vinfolio Marketplace should be listed on their site. We have a difference of opinion which has resulted for now in only listing "for sale" wine which has either a bid price or an asking price instead of all wine marked for sale.
While Vinfolio has a self-interest in having more listings, I happen to believe that any Winesearcher user would prefer to know a wine was potentially able to be purchased than to censor the information. In any case, I suggested to Winesearcher that we air the topic on an independent wine board to expose the topic to a broader audience. As the Squires board on eRobertParker.com determined my post violated their commercial policies (and deleted it within minutes), you can find my detailed post (and poll) on Wine Berserkers.
I'll be responding to comments on the Wine Berserkers thread as well as any which are posted here.
