|
|
International Wine Cellar
Author: Stephen Tanzer
Issue: Issue 111
|
(a selection of mostly old vines in the grand cru Osterberg) Aromas of lemon, mint and caraway seed. Creamier and sweeter than the "regular" Frederic Emile, with an almost exotic peachy ripeness and a strong spice character. This is wonderfully sweet and full, with considerable flesh on its bones. Finishes very long, fresh and tight, with the wine's strong underlying minerality making itself felt on the back end. I was shocked to be told that this wine was carrying only five grams of residual sugar. The impression of sweetness, according to Pierre Trimbach, is from the wine's huge dry extract.
|
Wine Advocate
Author: David Schildknecht
Issue: 175
|
The virtues of the 2001 Trimbach Rieslings will by now be well known to readers, but in another year or two they will release a 2001 Riesling Cuvee Frederic Emile 375th Anniversary representing a small lot of late-picked Osterberg. Smelling of honey and herbal elixir, it offers a creamy texture, refined peach, honey and mint flavors, and a vivid sense of salt, chalk and wet stone minerality. This might ultimately approach the quality of the 2001 Clos Ste-Hune, and will be one to enjoy over a twenty year period, as despite its elegance it is uncannily concentrated (and, incidentally, despite its richness perfectly dry).
|
Wine Spectator
Author: Bruce Sanderson
|
Starts austerely, but displays richness on the palate, with apple and quince notes. Reserved in a dry style that needs time to open. Good length.
|
|